Originally Posted by H3F Carnage

LMAO

Birant Westbrook wants 10 million/yr

give it to him he's worth it...

Originally Posted by Daredevil

give it to him he's worth it...

No 30 year old RB makes or will make 10 million a year.

LT only makes 7.

OMG the pre-season starts in 12 days yessssssss.

Originally Posted by H3F Carnage

No 30 year old RB makes or will make 10 million a year.

LT only makes 7.

Westbrook is the Eagles whole team every game they won last season had something to do with him.

cleveland browns.

Who cares what Westbrook wants he's not going to get that much because the Eagles don't operate that way. They put only a certain amount of money in each position and he's locked up for the next few years so he isn't going anywhere and he isn't holding out.

BTW Giants receiving core does suck and isn't even close to dallas for whoever said that.



Just so everyone knows Carnage hates Westbrook because I was right when I said Westbrook > Steve Smith.

Originally Posted by Keaver

Just so everyone knows Carnage hates Westbrook because I was right when I said Westbrook > Steve Smith.

I don't hate Westbrook, I just think it's funny that he assumes he can get the money he wants by hiring another agent. The agent is just going to screw him over and collect his money, while Westbrook is stuck in the same deal.


And Steve Smith is better than Westbrook, if it were an ESPN poll the only state that would say otherwise would be Pennsylvania.

Originally Posted by H3F Carnage

I don't hate Westbrook, I just think it's funny that he assumes he can get the money he wants by hiring another agent. The agent is just going to screw him over and collect his money, while Westbrook is stuck in the same deal.


And Steve Smith is better than Westbrook, if it were an ESPN poll the only state that would say otherwise would be Pennsylvania.

Steve Smith has 37 Career in 6 years played.
Westbrook has 52 in 5 years played.

Steve Smith has had 1 double digit touchdown season
Westbrook has had 3

Westbrook 1900 yards from scrimmage for a season 2 times
Steve Smith has never done that

Steve Smith broke 1,500 yards from scrimmage once
Westbrook did that 3 times

Steve Smith has 23 career fumbles
Westbrook has 10

Westbrook 7,992 yards from Scrimmage
Steve Smith 6,050 yards from scrimmage


I really don't have to say more, you overrate Steve Smith based off his 1 great season and if ESPN did a poll Westbrook would easily win it are you out of your mind? the voters would primarily be Fantasy Football players and Westbrook was the 4th best fantasy football player last year and the 3rd best runningback.

Originally Posted by Keaver

Steve Smith has 37 Career in 6 years played.
Westbrook has 52 in 5 years played.

I already proven how invalid your point is.


First and foremost Smith has only played 5 seasons as a receiver.

Second
Westbrook is a RB and gets 400+ touches per season in a West Coast offense.

He has 4,221 career touches compared to Steve Smith's 468.

He has gotten the ball 3,753 more times than Steve Smith.



And sadly Westbrook only has 27 rushing TDs, while having most of his TDs receiving.

Which I've already pointed out over the past 2 years to be a weak and easy gimmick for him to get because all of his passes are short and screens which place him against a LBer. A LBer is too slow to cover him effectively.

Steve Smith gets triple coverage with the free safety rolling to his side of the field. Not nearly as easy to get open and catch balls as it is for Westbrook to.

Not to mention the offensive scheme that Westbrook plays in. The West coast short dump offs are in no way amazing or should shape a players value as good. As a matter of fact it just pads his stats, otherwise Brees could be considered the best QB in the league.

Originally Posted by Keaver

Steve Smith has had 1 double digit touchdown season
Westbrook has had 3

LOL

Steve Smith is a wide receiver, and not a huge red zone threat. How many of those do you know that have double digit touchdown seasons?

The fact is they don't, and comparing the amount of touchdowns is stupid because Westbrook gets the ball many more times and in completely different ways.

Westbrook has had only 2 1,000 yard rushing seasons, where as 4 1,000 yard receiving seasons.

Originally Posted by Keaver

Westbrook 1900 Total yards for a season 2 times
Steve Smith has never done that

Wrong.

2003 Steve Smith had 1900 total yard

Originally Posted by Keaver

Steve Smith has 23 career fumbles
Westbrook has 10

Punt return and kick off return, and I already told you and posted that he hasn't lost as many as Westbrook has.

Steve Smith has lost 30% of his fumbles, Westbrook has lost 80% of his fumbles. Thus Westbrook turns the ball over more.

Originally Posted by Keaver

I really don't have to say more, you overrate Steve Smith based off his 1 great season

No, you're ignorant cause you don't watch him play. If you watched him play then you would know he is good. All you look as is the stats, which don't tell you the entire story to how good a player is.

And before you say so, I do and have watched Westbrook play.

Professional player analysts(the coaches and other players) will tell you. Steve Smith has been to the pro bowl 3 times, and been an all pro twice. Both are more than Westbrook.



Also Steve Smith has had 4 good seasons, and 1 historically amazing season. Where as Westbrook has only had 2 good seasons.

Originally Posted by Keaver

and if ESPN did a poll Westbrook would easily win it are you out of your mind? the voters would primarily be Fantasy Football players and Westbrook was the 4th best fantasy football player last year and the 3rd best runningback.

Fantasy football players don't account for the majority of votes on ESPN.com........maybe it was was solely posted in the FF section, but not the on the main page where a diverse range of people frequent.

LOL Brian Westbrook over Steve Smith?

What kind of idiot are you?