Halo 3 Forum
Welcome, Unregistered!
 | Don't have an account? Register Now!
Search:  Advanced Search
Halo 3 Forum: The Biggest Halo 3 Forum
Faith = Stupidity???
Lammie
Level 100 Jolteon
  #11 (permalink) Default 10-04-2006
 
Lammie's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: dazed and confused
Posts: 6,084

Send a message via AIM to Lammie

Quote:
Originally Posted by kn0xy
I understand and respect that, everyone's free to have their own opinions and beliefs...however, I just disagree and am not satisfied with the answers that theology gives on answers to these questions.
I think that religious people are grouped into the "stupid' category because stupid people often turn to religion. I've had my doubts about religion, but have been turned back each time without fail.
__________________
Thank you.




Not mentioned in signature: Rebal <3
Lammiespace.

*Hip Thrust*
 
Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links


Faith = Stupidity???
Darth Hulk
Level 34
  #12 (permalink) Default 10-04-2006
 
Darth Hulk's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Chillin' with Splinter
Posts: 2,895
Bungie Stats
Send a message via AIM to Darth Hulk

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lammie
As far as I am concerned, it would be completely irrational for there not to be a God, but the way I would explain it would be the same way you'd argue it, so it's kind of pointless.

I can, however, testify that my personal evidence is genuine. I am not a liar.

If you took a group of 1000 Christians and asked them to describe their experience of accepting Christ, I would bet that 950 of them would describe the same emotions, feelings, thoughts, and prayers, etc. It really is personal evidence, but that fact that so many Christians share nearly identical personal evidence in isolated incidents says SOMETHING about it.

In my reality, to believe that there is no God would be irrational. I believe Christianity is correct for various other reasons.

I have no interest in arguing against the existence God, I just would like to hear the "reasoning" that goes into your faith.


TMNT
__________________
The Dark Knight = God of movies
 
Reply With Quote
Faith = Stupidity???
Vagrant
Level 39
  #13 (permalink) Default 10-04-2006
 
Vagrant's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Smells like death
Posts: 4,170


Faith is just like a number of any other undeniable but irrational feelings that one can experience. Love is another. I have both and cherish them with equal amounts of enthusiasm.
 
Reply With Quote
Faith = Stupidity???
Lammie
Level 100 Jolteon
  #14 (permalink) Default 10-04-2006
 
Lammie's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: dazed and confused
Posts: 6,084

Send a message via AIM to Lammie

Quote:
Originally Posted by Darth Hulk
I have no interest in arguing against the existence God, I just would like to hear the "reasoning" that goes into your faith.


TMNT
It's really a manner of "feeling" the presense of God. There are certain times in a Christian's life where they experience what is called a "mountain top experience" where you feel as if you are as close to God as you could ever be, and it's quite overwhelming. To feel so small, insignificant, to feel so unworthy in the presense of a holy being is unreal. I believe that the God I know was and is there is the God described in Christianity.

You could call me crazy. Colostomizer calls it an internal placebo. I can definitely say that neither of these are true, but it's your job to believe me.
__________________
Thank you.




Not mentioned in signature: Rebal <3
Lammiespace.

*Hip Thrust*
 
Reply With Quote
Faith = Stupidity???
Darth Hulk
Level 34
  #15 (permalink) Default 10-04-2006
 
Darth Hulk's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Chillin' with Splinter
Posts: 2,895
Bungie Stats
Send a message via AIM to Darth Hulk

Quote:
Originally Posted by Vagrant
Faith is just like a number of any other undeniable but irrational feelings that one can experience. Love is another. I have both and cherish them with equal amounts of enthusiasm.

Love, as I understand it, is an emotion. Faith I don't think falls into that category as easily as you make it seem.


TMNT
__________________
The Dark Knight = God of movies
 
Reply With Quote
Faith = Stupidity???
Lammie
Level 100 Jolteon
  #16 (permalink) Default 10-04-2006
 
Lammie's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: dazed and confused
Posts: 6,084

Send a message via AIM to Lammie

Quote:
Originally Posted by Vagrant
Faith is just like a number of any other undeniable but irrational feelings that one can experience. Love is another. I have both and cherish them with equal amounts of enthusiasm.
I don't believe that love exists within the confines of the ideological definition we as a society have given it.

In all likelihood, I imagine that I will prove myself wrong one day, but until then I enjoy arguing about it.
__________________
Thank you.




Not mentioned in signature: Rebal <3
Lammiespace.

*Hip Thrust*
 
Reply With Quote
Faith = Stupidity???
Darth Hulk
Level 34
  #17 (permalink) Default 10-04-2006
 
Darth Hulk's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Chillin' with Splinter
Posts: 2,895
Bungie Stats
Send a message via AIM to Darth Hulk

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lammie
It's really a manner of "feeling" the presense of God. There are certain times in a Christian's life where they experience what is called a "mountain top experience" where you feel as if you are as close to God as you could ever be, and it's quite overwhelming. To feel so small, insignificant, to feel so unworthy in the presense of a holy being is unreal. I believe that the God I know was and is there is the God described in Christianity.

You could call me crazy. Colostomizer calls it an internal placebo. I can definitely say that neither of these are true, but it's your job to believe me.

I don't think you're crazy, I know what you are talking about because I used to be of the same religion as you. However, I would disagree that it is my job to believe you that it was God that made you feel this way. It's only my job to believe something if I have a reason to. As intelligent as you may or not be, you are no where near the level of intelligence to where I would take your statements regarding the existence of God based on the authority principle of knowledge. However, the part where I believe that people fall into that sort of trap is where parents teach their kids this stuff practically from birth. I was lucky I guess that my parents divorced and my dad never went to church, cause that got me out of that habit real fast and I saw it for what it really was, an unnecessary distraction in my life. I have seen many, many reasons for people believing in God and being religious, all I'm saying is that non of them are founded in reason and can therefore, by definition of the word, be called stupid.

If you are saying that you have real "evidence" that God exists then what you have is, by definition, not faith. Therefore, you actually "know" that God exists. That is a claim you are welcome to make, but would be hard pressed to prove.


TMNT
__________________
The Dark Knight = God of movies
 
Reply With Quote
Faith = Stupidity???
Lammie
Level 100 Jolteon
  #18 (permalink) Default 10-04-2006
 
Lammie's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: dazed and confused
Posts: 6,084

Send a message via AIM to Lammie

Quote:
Originally Posted by Darth Hulk
I don't think you're crazy, I know what you are talking about because I used to be of the same religion as you. However, I would disagree that it is my job to believe you that it was God that made you feel this way. It's only my job to believe something if I have a reason to. As intelligent as you may or not be, you are no where near the level of intelligence to where I would take your statements regarding the existence of God based on the authority principle of knowledge. However, the part where I believe that people fall into that sort of trap is where parents teach their kids this stuff practically from birth. I was lucky I guess that my parents divorced and my dad never went to church, cause that got me out of that habit real fast and I saw it for what it really was, an unnecessary distraction in my life. I have seen many, many reasons for people believing in God and being religious, all I'm saying is that non of them are founded in reason and can therefore, by definition of the word, be called stupid.

If you are saying that you have real "evidence" that God exists then what you have is, by definition, not faith. Therefore, you actually "know" that God exists. That is a claim you are welcome to make, but would be hard pressed to prove.


TMNT
When I said it was your job to believe, I was not implying that you were required to, or that you even should, convert to Christianity. My statement was essentially "Here is my story, take it for what you will." It was a figure of speech. I don't expect to convince you in 2 paragraphs, or 100 parapgraphs for that matter.

I consider myself different from the people who have been a Christian for "their entire lives". I was raised a Christian, but once I got smart enough to doubt it, I lived the life to appease my parents and church authorities, but didn't really believe. I think this gave me an advantage because I was and am knowledgable about the religion but didn't believe it at the time.

Since the time I accepted Christ about 4 summers ago, I have gone through many periods of questioning of my religion. There hasn't been anything yet to shake me enough to stop believing all together, but there have been times when it is close.

I do not claim to know 100% for a fact that there is a God. If I made that notion in a prior post, I apologize. I acknowledge that I could be wrong, as does MarkedAchilles with his conclusion about there beind no God. However, both of us are very confident in our view points. From our perspectives, it would be irrational to NOT believe what we believe.

My 'evidence' is worthless to anyone but me.
__________________
Thank you.




Not mentioned in signature: Rebal <3
Lammiespace.

*Hip Thrust*
 
Reply With Quote
Faith = Stupidity???
NiceGuy
Baby's Daddy, Scrooge
  #19 (permalink) Default 10-04-2006
 
NiceGuy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: is irrelevant
Posts: 20,367

Send a message via AIM to NiceGuy

As I understood it, people put faith in science, put faith in any kind of belief. Faith, to me, is personal affirmation; it holds no real value to other people, but the value to the individual is credible enough.
__________________

 
Reply With Quote
Faith = Stupidity???
Darth Hulk
Level 34
  #20 (permalink) Default 10-04-2006
 
Darth Hulk's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Chillin' with Splinter
Posts: 2,895
Bungie Stats
Send a message via AIM to Darth Hulk

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lammie
When I said it was your job to believe, I was not implying that you were required to, or that you even should, convert to Christianity. My statement was essentially "Here is my story, take it for what you will." It was a figure of speech. I don't expect to convince you in 2 paragraphs, or 100 parapgraphs for that matter.

I consider myself different from the people who have been a Christian for "their entire lives". I was raised a Christian, but once I got smart enough to doubt it, I lived the life to appease my parents and church authorities, but didn't really believe. I think this gave me an advantage because I was and am knowledgable about the religion but didn't believe it at the time.

Since the time I accepted Christ about 4 summers ago, I have gone through many periods of questioning of my religion. There hasn't been anything yet to shake me enough to stop believing all together, but there have been times when it is close.

I do not claim to know 100% for a fact that there is a God. If I made that notion in a prior post, I apologize. I acknowledge that I could be wrong, as does MarkedAchilles with his conclusion about there beind no God. However, both of us are very confident in our view points. From our perspectives, it would be irrational to NOT believe what we believe.

My 'evidence' is worthless to anyone but me.
The problem I find with people as I've said is that there is just not enough thinking going on when it comes to religion. There are a bunch of religions in this world, and many of them make conflicting claims meaning somebody is probably wrong. The devout followers of these religions are pretty much 100% confident that they are correct in there beliefs. That almost everyone doesn't see a big, bright red flag when they ponder this is astounding to me. To a nonsubscriber to religion like myself, it appears as if you are all delusional, and worse that you see the believers of other religions as equally delusional as they do you. Not you personally, Lammie, but I suspect you know what I mean. This is just one of the conundrums involved with religion that has recently been brought to my attention and that I would need resolved to have any notion that religion is not "stupid".

I'd like to point out again that I am not arguing against the existence of God, merely that religion is "stupid".


TMNT
__________________
The Dark Knight = God of movies
 
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:08 AM.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.2.0 ©2008, Crawlability, Inc.
Microsoft, Bungie and Halo are trademarks of Microsoft Corporation.

Banner Exchange