Halo 3 Forum
Welcome, Unregistered!
 | Don't have an account? Register Now!
Search:  Advanced Search
Halo 3 Forum: The Biggest Halo 3 Forum
The Case for Agnosticism
The Colostomizer
Rear Admiral
  #161 (permalink) Default 09-03-2006
 
The Colostomizer's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2005
Posts: 4,882

Send a message via AIM to The Colostomizer Send a message via MSN to The Colostomizer Send a message via Yahoo to The Colostomizer

Quote:
Originally Posted by mrmuushu
What makes Agnoticism better than Creationism? Basically in both cases a believer would be under the impression that the creator made us and then parted ways.
Whoa, slow down. Agnostics are under no impressions whatsoever. Quote me on whatever made you think that, and I'll clarify.

There may or may not be a creator. As an agnostic, I can't say for sure either way.
__________________


 
Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links


The Case for Agnosticism
mrmuushu
Level 31
  #162 (permalink) Default 09-03-2006
 
mrmuushu's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Georgia
Posts: 2,202


Quote:
Originally Posted by The Colostomizer
Whoa, slow down. Agnostics are under no impressions whatsoever. Quote me on whatever made you think that, and I'll clarify.

There may or may not be a creator. As an agnostic, I can't say for sure either way.
Yeah after I made that post I realized that people who follow Creationism would have to believe more strongly that there was a maker. I was just thinking that since you were leaning more towards there being a creator, that would an avenue worth looking at.
 
Reply With Quote
The Case for Agnosticism
Haqqul_Yaqeen
uber n00b (level 2)
  #163 (permalink) Default 09-04-2006
 
Haqqul_Yaqeen's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: New York City
Posts: 3

Send a message via AIM to Haqqul_Yaqeen Send a message via MSN to Haqqul_Yaqeen Send a message via Yahoo to Haqqul_Yaqeen

Hello everyone,

Before I say anything I must warn you that sometimes I talk a lot. (Or maybe I just said that to use that emoticon which I found really cute...)

Anyway this is my first post on this forum, The Colostomizer asked me to join and comment on this thread. Why me? 'Cause I'm special...well, actually cause I'm Muslim, but that makes me special. Yes it does. YES IT DOES!

On a more serious note, yes it does.

Quote:
I have never heard a Muslim describe a personal relationship with Allah. In Islam, they live their life, and if Allah decides that the good outweighs the bad, they live in paradise.
Without a personal relationship with Allah, I don't know how someone can really consider themselves Muslim at all. Take praying, for example...it's a bunch of moves put together, and anyone can do it. The thing that makes it real is feeling a relationship with God, a connection not really felt with anyone else. Islam definitely isn't only actions or deeds, but faith plus deeds.

Anyway just wanted to point that out. Although I think we're starting with details before the basics...and anyone who wants to learn about Islam should really learn the basics first.
 
Reply With Quote
The Case for Agnosticism
666
Level 16
  #164 (permalink) Default 09-04-2006
 
666's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: near Londonistan, UK
Posts: 325

Send a message via AIM to 666

Quote:
Originally Posted by The Colostomizer
The purpose of this thread is to prove that agnosticism is the best way to go.
You lost me at 'prove'
__________________




XBL: Humming Snail
AIM: ThirdEyeInfancy

probably the number 1 fan of Synapse
 
Reply With Quote
The Case for Agnosticism
The Colostomizer
Rear Admiral
  #165 (permalink) Default 09-04-2006
 
The Colostomizer's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2005
Posts: 4,882

Send a message via AIM to The Colostomizer Send a message via MSN to The Colostomizer Send a message via Yahoo to The Colostomizer

Quote:
Originally Posted by 666
You lost me at 'prove'
If every other option is unacceptable, agnosticism must be the best way to go, right?
__________________


 
Reply With Quote
The Case for Agnosticism
Lammie
Level 100 Jolteon
  #166 (permalink) Default 09-04-2006
 
Lammie's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: dazed and confused
Posts: 6,084

Send a message via AIM to Lammie

Quote:
Originally Posted by Haqqul_Yaqeen
Hello everyone,

Before I say anything I must warn you that sometimes I talk a lot. (Or maybe I just said that to use that emoticon which I found really cute...)

Anyway this is my first post on this forum, The Colostomizer asked me to join and comment on this thread. Why me? 'Cause I'm special...well, actually cause I'm Muslim, but that makes me special. Yes it does. YES IT DOES!

On a more serious note, yes it does.


Without a personal relationship with Allah, I don't know how someone can really consider themselves Muslim at all. Take praying, for example...it's a bunch of moves put together, and anyone can do it. The thing that makes it real is feeling a relationship with God, a connection not really felt with anyone else. Islam definitely isn't only actions or deeds, but faith plus deeds.

Anyway just wanted to point that out. Although I think we're starting with details before the basics...and anyone who wants to learn about Islam should really learn the basics first.
I hope you're here to stay and not just for a short visit. It would be nice to have some Muslims around, different viewpoints are always nice.

But isn't it true that you cannot be sure of where your afterlife will be? That if your good outweighs your bad on a scale, you get into paradise, but you can't really be positive? That ultimately Allah decides, and that even Mohammed (spelling? sorry) didn't know if he'd get to paradise?

How do you know that Allah loves you? Does Allah love you?

What exactly does your faith entail, aside from deeds?
__________________
Thank you.




Not mentioned in signature: Rebal <3
Lammiespace.

*Hip Thrust*
 
Reply With Quote
The Case for Agnosticism
Haqqul_Yaqeen
uber n00b (level 2)
  #167 (permalink) Default 09-04-2006
 
Haqqul_Yaqeen's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: New York City
Posts: 3

Send a message via AIM to Haqqul_Yaqeen Send a message via MSN to Haqqul_Yaqeen Send a message via Yahoo to Haqqul_Yaqeen

Quote:
Originally Posted by TeH 3quivocat0r
I hope you're here to stay and not just for a short visit. It would be nice to have some Muslims around, different viewpoints are always nice.
You seem pretty open minded. That's one of the best qualities someone can have. Yes, hopefully I'll stay as long as I'm welcome here.

Quote:
But isn't it true that you cannot be sure of where your afterlife will be?
Paradise is promised to the believers, who fear Allah and put their trust in Him, and struggle within themselves against their desires to sin. And hell is promised to the disbelievers, who do the opposite of that.

But in general, can anyone really be sure of anything that will happen in the future? I'd think the answer is no, and so I can't be sure whether I'm going to Paradise or Hell, but let me ask you this: Are my chances of going to Paradise really the same if I am devout and pious and humble as if I go to nightclubs every night and drink, and live carelessly? Obviously you get what you pay for. Likewise, you get what you work for.

Quote:
That ultimately Allah decides, and that even Mohammed (spelling? sorry) didn't know if he'd get to paradise?
Ultimately Allah decides, but Allah isn't cruel or unfair. He'll decide based on your actions in this world. To put it simply, this life is a test. You're being tested of 1) your belief in God and His messengers, Angels, Book, etc. etc., 2) your actions.

It isn't a trick. God isn't out to get you. It's really a universal idea; you work, you become successful. You slack off, you lose.

Quote:
How do you know that Allah loves you? Does Allah love you?
There are signs of Allah's love. I can list them, but first I have to know how much you know about Islam. Do you know the basics? If you know the basics I can go on.

Quote:
What exactly does your faith entail, aside from deeds?
Ok, we believe there are more than 70 branches of faith. These branches are divided into three parts:

1) Action of the heart (i.e. belief)
2) Action of the tongue (i.e. declaration)
3) Action of all other parts of the body (i.e. action upon belief)

You can go here to read a compiled list of those branches:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iman_(concept)

Basically, if one has all those qualities, he/she has complete faith. Also, I'm sure you know about the 5 pillars of Islam. If one follows those, he/she is a believer and a Muslim, but can always strive to improve by trying to implement the (more than) 70 branches of faith.

I hope that answers your question, if you have any more please don't hesitate to ask.
__________________
Haqqul Yaqeen means Truth of Certainty...whoever wants to learn more about this, i.e. Islam, please contact me (AIM, Yahoo, or MSN). I'll answer any questions you have, and debate with you if you feel that I'm wrong. In fact, I challenge you to prove me wrong...unless you weren't originally planning on doing that, in which case I withdraw the challenge. Also, if you want to join an Islamic Forum and speak with countless Muslims about anything you want, go to www.gawaher.com.

Last edited by Haqqul_Yaqeen; 09-04-2006 at 09:41 PM.
 
Reply With Quote
The Case for Agnosticism
666
Level 16
  #168 (permalink) Default 09-05-2006
 
666's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: near Londonistan, UK
Posts: 325

Send a message via AIM to 666

Quote:
Originally Posted by The Colostomizer
If every other option is unacceptable, agnosticism must be the best way to go, right?
the reason he lost me at 'prove' is because he can't prove that every other option is unacceptable.
__________________




XBL: Humming Snail
AIM: ThirdEyeInfancy

probably the number 1 fan of Synapse
 
Reply With Quote
The Case for Agnosticism
The Colostomizer
Rear Admiral
  #169 (permalink) Default 09-05-2006
 
The Colostomizer's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2005
Posts: 4,882

Send a message via AIM to The Colostomizer Send a message via MSN to The Colostomizer Send a message via Yahoo to The Colostomizer

Quote:
Originally Posted by 666
the reason he lost me at 'prove' is because he can't prove that every other option is unacceptable.
If all possibilities are mutually exclusive (one has to be true, and only one can be true), then proving one disproves all of the others. Agreed?
__________________


 
Reply With Quote
The Case for Agnosticism
Lammie
Level 100 Jolteon
  #170 (permalink) Default 09-05-2006
 
Lammie's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: dazed and confused
Posts: 6,084

Send a message via AIM to Lammie

Quote:
Originally Posted by Haqqul_Yaqeen
There are signs of Allah's love. I can list them, but first I have to know how much you know about Islam. Do you know the basics? If you know the basics I can go on.
To be honest with you, the only side of Islam I've ever really heard was that of a Muslim turned Christian who was comparing the two.

How would you personally compare Islam to Christianity? How are the similar, and how are their Gods different (disregarding Jesus' death on the Cross)?
__________________
Thank you.




Not mentioned in signature: Rebal <3
Lammiespace.

*Hip Thrust*
 
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:11 AM.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.2.0 ©2008, Crawlability, Inc.
Microsoft, Bungie and Halo are trademarks of Microsoft Corporation.

Banner Exchange