Welcome to my motage review thread. I just want to give my opinion on the recent montages that will be in the contest. If you have any comments, good or bad, leave them here. NOTE : I will only review montages that are in the contest.

*Hit Ctrl + "F" to find a Montage

The Montages wil be listed in alphabetical order and in this format.
Montage Name (link to montage connected)
Filmer
Editor
Gamplay #/10
Pro's/Con's
Editing #/10

Pro'/Con's
Video Qulaity #/10
Pro's/Con's
Audio Selection #/10
Pro's/Con's
Overal (Average Scores)/10

ArKiVe Montage 3
Gameplay by : ArKiVe
Edited by : ArKiVe
Gameplay : 8.5/10
+ Great Snipes, Sticks
+ Nice Multi-Kills
- Not as much variety as I would like. The snipes were great, but it was just head-shot after head-shot after head-shot
Editing : 9/10
+ Great intro. Very unique and original
+ Okay A/V sinking for the song. It is a hard song to sinc to
+ Pretty basic editing. No flashes every 5 seconds, which I liked
- The sinking was not the best, but it was a hard song, but still could have been better
Video Quality : 8.5/10
+ Pretty good overall quality
- Just a little bit fuzzier than average
Audio Selection : 8.5/10
+Love RATM
- Not the greatest song to use A/V sincing, which is major
Overall : 8.625/10

Arpus Montage 2
Gameplay by : Arpus
Edited by : Halzred
Gameplay : 8.5/10
+ Nice Multi-Kills
Editing : 8.5/10
+ Good A/V sinking
Video Quality : 7.5/10
~ Average at best
Audio Selection : 8/10
+ Goos song for a montage
- Been used ALOT
Overall : 8.125/10

Bigmac2121 Montage 1
Gameplay by : Bigmac2121
Edited by : MikeMan27
Gameplay : 8.5/10
+ Lots of variety
+ Nice Multi-Kills
+ Good Snipes, Sticks
- Some non-deserving plays
Editing : 8.5/10
+ Good A/V synching
Video Quality : 8/10
~ Average Quality
Audio Selection : 8/10
~ That genre is okay IMO. Not good, not bad
Overall : 8.25/10

Captain 67 & MikeMan27 Montage
Gameplay by : Captain 67 & MikeMan27
Edited by : MikeMan27
Gameplay : 8.5/10
+ Nice Multi-Kills
+ Nice BxR's, Snipes, Sticks
- Only a few of clips that I didn't like
Editing : 8.5/10
+ Very good A/V synching. You always do that nicely
+ Pretty basic editing. Nothing big and flashy, which I liked
- Not really a bad thing, but maybe a couple good effects needed, but not a must
Video Quality : 8.5/10
+ Okay overall quality
- Just a little bit fuzzier than average
Audio Selection : 8.5/10
+ Loved the songs
+ Good selection to esit with
Overall : 8.95/10

Chris The Hippie Volume 2
Gameplay by : Chris The Hippie
Edited by : Chris The Hippie
Gameplay : 8.5/10
+ Great Snipes (Especially BxR Snipes)
+ Great Sticks
+ Nice Multi-Kills
- Not really a bad point, but just not anything that great
Editing : 9.5/10
+ Loved the intro. Very original and very creative
+ Syncing was meh, but you might have been going for more of an oldschool thing, idk.
+ Very nice effects thrown in there
- Couldn't really find anything I didn't like.
Video Quality : 9/10
+ Very very good qulaity.
Audio Selection : 8.5/10
+ Loved your selections
- Not the best choice for a montage IMO
Overall : 8.875/10

DeTeef Montage 2
Gameplay by : Deteef
Edited by : Deteef
Gameplay : 8.5/10
+ Good Multi-Kills
+ Good Sticks, Snipes
- Some stuff stuff that shouldn't have been in there.
Editing : 8.5/10
+ Some good effects here and there
+ Pretty good A/V synching
+ Intro was unique
Video Quality : 8.5/10
+ Pretty good qulaity
Audio Selection : 8/10
+ Songs were average IMO
Overall : 8.375/10

GoatCheeze Montage 2
Gameplay by : GoatCheeze
Edited by : GoatCheeze
Gameplay : 7.5/10
+ Good Snipes
+ Good Multi-Kills
- Nothing reall amazing, which isn't bad
- ALOT of that stuff shouldn't have been in there.
Editing : 7.5/10
+ Some good effects here and there
- Virtually no synching at all
- Not really any sort of intro, it was really short, and not up to today's standards.
- Song could have been used alot better
Video Quality : 9/10
+ Pretty good qulaity.
Audio Selection : 8/10
+ Can be a good montage song, if edited well
- I hate that song, but that is just me
Overall : 8./10

H4LVoid Montage 4
Gameplay by : H4LVoid
Edited by : H4LVoid
Gameplay : 8/10
+ Good Multi-kills
+ Good snipes, sticks
Editing : 8/10
+ Good A/V synching
- Alot of easy, non-needed effects
Video Quality : 8/10
+ Good qulaity.
Audio Selection : 8/10
~ Not a bad song, not a good song
Overall : 8/10

HaloGod Montage 3
Gameplay by : HaloGod
Edited by : HaloGod
Gameplay : 8/10
+ Good Sticks
- Not alot of variety
- Not the greatest snipes or multi-kills
Editing : 8.5/10
+ Good A/V synching
Video Quality : 9/10
+ Very nice qulaity.
Audio Selection : 8.5/10
+ Good Song for a montage
+ original genre and song
Overall : 8.5/10

Halzred Montage 5
Gameplay by : Halzred
Edited by : Halzred
Gameplay : 8/10
+ Good muti-kills,sticks
~ Not the greatest gameplay, but good
Editing : 9/10
+ Great Effects
+ Great A/V synching
- Just a little bit too much at 1 time
Video Quality : 8.5/10
+ Nice qulaity.
Audio Selection : 9/10
+ Good Song for a montage
+ Original song
Overall : 8.625/10


HOOk3d on Chron1c Montage : Reflection
Gameplay by : HOOk3d on Chron1c
Edited by : HOOk3d on Chron1c
Gameplay : 9/10
+ Great Multi Kills
+ Alot of variety
Editing : 8/10
+ Love the "Old-School" Style
- Not really any editing at all, including intro. A montage has to have some IMO
Video Quality : 8.5/10
+ Average qulaity at best
Audio Selection : 9/10
+ Good song for a montage
+ Original and song
Overall : 8.625/10

ItWasLuck Montage 5
Gameplay by : ItWasLuck
Edited by : MikeMan27
Gameplay : 9.5/10
+ PRO'S
+ LOTS of Multi-kills
+ Good snipes, sticks, bxr's
+ Lots of variety
Editing : 8.5/10
+ Great A/V synching
Video Quality : 9/10
+ Very nice qulaity.
Audio Selection : 9/10
+ Good Song for a montage
+ original genre and song
Overall : 9/10

Kiwi Montage 5
Gameplay by : Kiwi
Edited by : Kiwi
Gameplay : 8.5/10
+ Great snipes, sticks
+ Lots of variety
Editing : 9/10
+ Great A/V synching
+ Some nice effects
Video Quality : 9.5/10
+ Great qulaity.
Audio Selection : 8.5/10
+ Good Song for a montage
Overall : 8.875/10

Kn0xy Montage 3
Gameplay by : Kn0xy
Edited by : Kn0xy
Gameplay : 9/10
+ Great snipes, sticks
+ Lots of variety
+ Great Multi-kills
Editing : 9/10
+ Good A/V synching
+ Some nice effects
Video Quality : 9/10
+ Very good qulaity.=
Audio Selection : 8.5/10
+ Great Song for a montage
- It has been used alot before
Overall : 8.875/10

Leprickahn/Cyb3rBully Montage
Gameplay by : Leprickahn/Cyb3rbully
Edited by : Leprickahn
Gameplay : 8.5/10
+ Great snipes, sticks
+ Lots of variety
+ Good Multiples
- Just a few that I did not like that dropeed this score
Editing : 8.5/10
+ Great A/V synching
+ Some nice effects
- Very inconsistent
- Maybe too much flashy/wavy stuff
Video Quality : 9/10
+ Great qulaity
Audio Selection : 8.5/10
+ Okay song
Overall : 8.625/10

Lithium Montage 1
Gameplay by : Lithium
Edited by : SDN Jada 1
Gameplay : 9/10
+ Great snipes, sticks
+ Lots of variety
+ Great Multi-kills
Editing : 9/10
+ Great A/V synching
+ Some nice effects
Video Quality : 8/10
~ Average at best
Audio Selection : 9/10
+ Loved this song
Overall : 8.75/10

NoKTurNals Montage 4
Gameplay by : NoKTurNaL
Edited by : Chris The Hippie
Gameplay : 9/10
+ Great Snipes, Sticks
+ Nice Multi-Kills
+ Lots of variety
Editing : 9.5/10
+ Amazing intro
+ Good A/V synching
+ Great effects
Video Quality : 8.5/10
+ Good overall quality
Audio Selection : 8.5/10
+ I do not lie rap, but it worked
Overall : 8.875/10

OlManMakowski Montage 4
Gameplay by : 'Ol Man Makowski
Edited by : Kn0xy
Gameplay : 10/10
+ The only Montage in this contest with good H1 footage
+ LOTS of Pro's
+ GREAT Multi-Kills
+ Lots of great snipes, sticks
Editing : 8.5/10
+ Good A/V synching
- Too much wave/tv effect.
Video Quality : 9/10
+ Good quality
Audio Selection : 9/10
+ Good song for a montage
+ Original song
Overall : 9.125/10

Pan1c & Uminator Montage
Gameplay by : Uminator & Pan1c
Edited by : Pan1c
Gameplay : 8.5/10
+ Good Multi-Kills
+ Lots of great snipes
Editing : 9/10
+ Loved the intro. Very nice
+ Good A/V synching
Video Quality : 8.5/10
+ Good quality
Audio Selection : 8.5/10
+ Good song for a montage
+ Original song
Overall : 8.625/10

Quick-Pro Montage 1
Gameplay by : Quick-Pro
Edited by : Quick-Pro
Gameplay : 8/10
+ Nice Multi-kills
Editing : 8/10
~ Not alot of edtiting, but it was good
Video Quality : 8/10
~ Average at best
Audio Selection : 8/10
+ Liked the songs
- A little bit over-used
Overall : 8/10

Quix Montage 1
Gameplay by : Quix
Edited by : Quix
Gameplay : 9/10
+ Nice Multi-kills
+ Lots of Pro's
Editing : 8.5/10
~ Average
Video Quality : 9/10
+ Good quality
Audio Selection : 8.5/10
+ Good song for a montage
Overall : 8.75/10

Reid18 Montage 3
Gameplay by : VReid18
Edited by : Reid18
Gameplay : 9/10
+ DISGUSTING sticks
+ Great snipes, multi-kills
Editing : 8.5/10
+ Basic, but good editing
Video Quality : 9/10
+ Good quality
Audio Selection : 8.5/10
+ Good song for a montage
- Second song is way over-used
Overall : 8.75/10

Titan/Maddog Montage
Gameplay by : Titan/Maddog
Edited by : Titan
Gameplay : 9/10
+ Great snipes, sticks
+ Great multi-kills
Editing : 9/10
+ Love the oldschool part
+ Good A/V synching
+ Good effects
Video Quality : 8.5/10
+ Pretty good
Audio Selection : 9/10
+ Good songs
+ Original songs
Overall : 8.875/10

Underdogg Montage 2
Gameplay by : Underdogg
Edited by : Slahs RF
Gameplay : 8/10
+ Good Stick, Snipes
+ Good Muti-kills
~Average at best
Editing : 8/10
~ Again, average
Video Quality : 7/10
- Not good
Audio Selection : 8/10
- Overused songs
Overall : 7.75/10

Vrbas Montage 4
Gameplay by : Vrbas
Edited by : Vrbas
Gameplay : 8/10
+ GREAT No-scopes
+ Nice Sticks
- Not alot of variety
Editing : 9/10
+ Classic Vrbas style
Video Quality : 9/10
+ Good quality
Audio Selection : 8.5/10
+ Good song for a montage
- Genre is not the geratest IMO
Overall : 8.625/10

LEADERBOARDS

Gameplay
'Ol Man Makowski = 10
ItWasLuck = 9.5
HOOk3d on Chron1c = 9
NokTurNaL = 9
Titan/Maddog = 9
Kn0xy = 9
Reid18 = 9
Quix = 9
ArKiVe = 8.5
Captain 67/Mikeman27 = 8.5

Editing

Chris The Hippie = 9.5
NoKTurNal = 9.5
Titan/Maddog = 9
Halzred = 9
Pan1c/Uminator = 9
Vrbas = 9
Kiwi (5) = 9
Kn0xy = 9
ArKiVe = 9
HaloGod = 8.5

Video Quality

Kiwi (5) = 9.5
Kiwi (4) = 9.5
ItWasLuck = 9
Vrbas = 9
HaloGod = 9
Kn0xy = 9
Reid18 = 9
Quix = 9
Chris The Hippie = 9
OlManMakowski = 9

OVERALL LEADERS
OlManMakowski Montage 4 = 9.125
ItWasLuck Montage 5 = 9
Kiwi Montage 5 = 8.875
Titan/Maddog Montage = 8.875
NoKTurNaL Montage 4 = 8.875
Kn0xy Montage 3 = 8.875
Chris The Hippie Volume 2 = 8.875
Reid18 Montage 3 = 8.75
Litium = 8.75
Quix Montage 1 = 8.75
Pan1c & Uminator Monatge = 8.625
HOOk3d on Chron1c Montage : Reflection = 8.625
Halzred Montage 5 = 8.625
Arkive Montage 3 = 8.625
Leprickahn/Cyb3rbully = 8.625
Vrbas Montage 4 = 8.625
MikeMan27 & Captain 67 = 8.5
HaloGod Montage 3 = 8.5
DeTeef Montage 2 = 8.375
Bigmac2121 Montage 1 = 8.25
Arpus Montage = 8.125
Quick-Pro Montage 1 = 8
GoatCheeze Montage 2 = 8
H4LVoid Montage 4 = 8
Underdogg Montage 2 = 7.75

Doesn't Lithium already do this?

well gg, so far just remember its synching* .. Not being a prick just helping you out.

Originally Posted by eric6879

Doesn't Lithium already do this?

Yes, and it is a very good thread, but this one only includes ones in the montage.

Originally Posted by CraftyVertan

Yes, and it is a very good thread, but this one only includes ones in the montage.

Well then... Good sh.t... You got a lot of work on ur hand, now. Lol.

Originally Posted by eric6879

Well then... Good sh.t... You got a lot of work on ur hand, now. Lol.

Yeah I do, I will be working on it all day. Hopefully people like it. And feel free, everyone, to post you opinions on the listed montages and the thread in general.

well i think that you did a good job with this so far, but............theres no way that of all the reviews you have made ChrisTheHippie v2 can have the highest overall. IMO that montage shouldnt have gotten hosted. Its practically all single snipes. This is my only problem with the reviews.

Originally Posted by I TM4C I

well i think that you did a good job with this so far, but............theres no way that of all the reviews you have made ChrisTheHippie v2 can have the highest overall. IMO that montage shouldnt have gotten hosted. Its practically all single snipes. This is my only problem with the reviews.

Yeah, I think it is the best out of the ones I have put up there, but maybe I made it too high of a rating. I will have another look at it.

Yeah...Chris' editing is definitely very good, but his gameplay is lacking...

I also don't know about the syncing with ArKiVe, I do know when I was editing the part near the end he was a montage nazi about how the syncing had to be exact.

ps. review mine.